Concept 1 of 71 min
Cost of carry and the convenience yield
A fair forward
| Spot | 60 |
|---|---|
| Financing | 4% a year |
| Storage | 1.5 a year |
- Financing = 60 × 4% = 2.4
- Forward ≈ 60 + 2.4 + 1.5 = 63.9
The forward is spot plus the cost of carrying the commodity.
Cash and carry
| Spot | 50 |
|---|---|
| 6-month future | 56 |
| Carry, 6 months | 3.5 |
- Profit = 56 − 50 − 3.5 = 2.5 a unit
Buying spot, storing and delivering locks in 2.5.
Backwardation
| Copper spot | 9,500 |
|---|---|
| 1-year future | 9,200 |
- Future below spot: 9,200 against 9,500
Despite positive rates and storage: a high convenience yield, metal scarce now.
A forward above full carry can be arbitraged by buying spot and selling forward. Backwardation despite positive carry means the physical good is scarce.
Anyone can buy the commodity today, pay to finance and store it, and deliver it later: that sets a ceiling on the forward.
Holding the barrel or the metal also has a value, the convenience yield, for instance keeping a refinery or a factory running, and when stocks are tight it can exceed the carry, pushing the forward below spot.
Arbitraging that would need someone to lend the physical good, which holders will not do cheaply. Gold is plentiful in storage, so its forward stays close to spot plus financing, with lease rates explaining small gaps.
- Forgetting storage, or the financing, in the forward.
- Calling a forward below spot mispriced when carry is positive: it signals scarcity.
- Taking the convenience yield for the interest earned on margin.
How would you price a 1-year forward on a barrel of oil, and why might the market price differ?
A complete answer covers
- Spot plus the cost of financing and storing the barrel for a year.
- A forward above that lets you buy spot, store and sell forward at a profit.
- A forward below it reflects the convenience yield of having oil now.
- Tight inventories push the curve into backwardation.
Also in our technical interviews, on camera, with a score.
Concept 2 of 71 min
Contango, backwardation and the roll
The why, the charts, the worked example and the interview questions are in Essentials, with every quiz.
See the plansSign inConcept 3 of 71 min
Futures, calendar spreads and benchmarks
The why, the charts, the worked example and the interview questions are in Essentials, with every quiz.
See the plansSign inConcept 4 of 71 min
Hedging producers and consumers
The why, the charts, the worked example and the interview questions are in Essentials, with every quiz.
See the plansSign inConcept 5 of 71 min
Crack and spark spreads
The why, the charts, the worked example and the interview questions are in Essentials, with every quiz.
See the plansSign inConcept 6 of 71 min
Carbon, Dr Copper and gas volatility
The why, the charts, the worked example and the interview questions are in Essentials, with every quiz.
See the plansSign inConcept 7 of 71 min
AdvancedStorage caps contango, until it runs out
The why, the charts, the worked example and the interview questions are in Essentials, with every quiz.
See the plansSign inRecap
- Forward = spot × (1 + financing) + storage, minus the convenience yield of holding the physical good; a forward above full carry is an arbitrage.
- Contango: later months above spot, rolling a long position costs money; backwardation: prompt above later months, when stocks are scarce.
- A long-only commodity index earns spot moves, roll yield and the interest on its collateral.
- Producers sell forward or buy puts, consumers buy forward or buy calls; a collar funds the floor with a cap; proxy hedges leave basis risk.
- Crack and spark spreads measure processing margins; gas and power options are dearest on the upside, where supply shocks bite.
25 questions on Commodities
Timed, like the real one, drawn from a bank of 33. Every answer explained.