Concept 1 of 111 min
Accretive or dilutive: the cost of the money
The cost of the money
| Buyer's P/E | 20x |
|---|---|
| Price paid | 15x earnings |
| Debt cost, pre-tax | 5% |
| Tax rate | 25% |
| After tax | 0.75 |
- Target's yield = 1 ÷ 15 ≈ 6.7%
- Debt after tax = 5% × 0.75 = 3.75%
- New shares = 1 ÷ 20 = 5%
Both costs are below 6.7%, so the deal is accretive either way.
- Per euro, per year · both below 6.7%: accretive
The earnings yield is the P/E turned upside down: what each euro of price earns in a year.
Paying cash gives up the interest that cash earned, after tax; borrowing costs interest, after tax since interest is deductible; issuing shares hands over a slice of the buyer's own earnings, at the buyer's own yield.
If what the target brings per euro beats what the money costs per euro, EPS goes up. In an all-stock deal this becomes a P/E test: buying a lower P/E than your own is accretive, a higher one dilutive, whatever the growth story.
Synergies, fees, the extra depreciation from purchase accounting and currency moves can change the answer, which is why bankers build the full pro forma.
- Comparing the pre-tax interest rate with the earnings yield: 8% before tax looks dearer than a 7% yield, but 8% × (1 − 25%) = 6% after tax, so the deal is accretive.
- Forgetting the new shares in the denominator: the target's earnings come with more shares.
- Adding synergies before tax: they are taxed like any other profit.
- Ignoring currency: if the target earns in a currency that then falls, its profit is worth less in the buyer's currency while the financing cost stays put, and accretion shrinks.
In an all-stock deal, how can you tell quickly whether the acquisition will be accretive or dilutive?
A buyer pays cash for a target. Its cash earned 3% before tax and the tax rate is 25%. Up to what P/E is the deal accretive?
Also in our technical interviews, on camera, with a score.
Concept 2 of 111 min
Accretion is not value creation
The why, the charts, the worked example and the interview questions are in Essentials, with every quiz.
See the plansSign inConcept 3 of 111 min
Valuing synergies
The why, the charts, the worked example and the interview questions are in Essentials, with every quiz.
See the plansSign inConcept 4 of 111 min
Purchase accounting and goodwill
The why, the charts, the worked example and the interview questions are in Essentials, with every quiz.
See the plansSign inConcept 5 of 111 min
The offer price, its premium and its multiple
The why, the charts, the worked example and the interview questions are in Essentials, with every quiz.
See the plansSign inConcept 7 of 111 min
Deal terms that protect each side
The why, the charts, the worked example and the interview questions are in Essentials, with every quiz.
See the plansSign inConcept 8 of 111 min
Hostile bids and defences
The why, the charts, the worked example and the interview questions are in Essentials, with every quiz.
See the plansSign inConcept 9 of 111 min
Asset deal, share deal, spin-off
The why, the charts, the worked example and the interview questions are in Essentials, with every quiz.
See the plansSign inConcept 10 of 111 min
The sale process and approvals
The why, the charts, the worked example and the interview questions are in Essentials, with every quiz.
See the plansSign inConcept 11 of 111 min
AdvancedThe most a buyer can pay in stock
The why, the charts, the worked example and the interview questions are in Essentials, with every quiz.
See the plansSign inRecap
- A deal is accretive when the target's earnings yield at the price paid beats the after-tax cost of the money: the rate × (1 − tax) for cash or debt, 1 ÷ the buyer's P/E for new shares.
- Accretion is not value: the buyer's shareholders gain only if the price is below the target's standalone value plus the synergies.
- Value synergies after tax, discounted for any delay, minus integration costs; trust cost synergies more than revenue synergies.
- Goodwill = price − fair value of the identifiable net assets, after deferred tax on the write-ups; the target's old goodwill disappears.
- A fixed exchange ratio leaves the price risk with the target's holders; break fees, reverse fees, earn-outs and a 90% condition share out the rest.
25 questions on M&A deals
Timed, like the real one, drawn from a bank of 34. Every answer explained.