Markets

Market-making and trading games

Play the trading interview games well: centre a market on expected value, read what each trade tells you, manage your inventory, and size bets with Kelly.

Read first: Probability and brainteasers

8 concepts10 min read25-question test, from a bank of 33Updated

Concept 1 of 81 min

Making a market

The rule
A two-sided market is a tight spread centred on your expected value, and you buy on the other side's offer and sell on its bid.
Worked examples

Two traders, one contract

Given
Pays100
Probability40%
One trader offers34
Another bids46
  1. Value = 100 × 40% = 40
  2. Buy at 34, sell at 46: 46 − 34 = 12

Two quotes on the wrong sides of fair value lock in 12 whatever happens.

Quoting a coin flip

Given
Pays on heads20
Heads50%
  1. Fair value = 0.5 × 20 = 10
  2. Quote 9 / 11, tight around it

A tight market around fair value invites trades both ways.

Buying where they sell

Given
Their market20 / 22
Your value25
  1. Buy at 22, their offer
  2. Edge = 25 − 22 = 3

You can only buy where the other trader sells.

The picture
Formula
Mid=expected value
95% range ≈ mean ± 2 standard deviations
coin flips: standard deviation=√(n × ¼)
Why it holds

Prices that let someone buy below and sell above fair value are taken on both sides. A very large size or a hidden direction calls for a wider spread.

A market nobody can lose on, such as 0 / 10 on a coin paying 10, is a market nobody trades; interviewers want a tight market around a reasoned estimate.

When someone quotes below your value, lift their offer; you cannot buy on a bid. If one counterpart sells below fair value and another buys above it, doing both locks in the gap whatever happens.

Large size carries more information and more market impact, so dealers widen to be paid for it.

For estimation markets, such as the number of US states whose names start with a letter, reason out loud, then quote around the estimate; for counts of random events, use the mean and the standard deviation.

Watch out
  • Centring on the middle of the range instead of the expected value.
  • Buying on a bid, or selling on an offer.
  • Quoting the normal tight price for a huge order of unknown direction.
In the interview
  1. I ask you to make me a market on how many piano tuners work in London. How do you go about it?

    A complete answer covers

    • Build an estimate out loud: population, pianos per household, tunings a year, tunings per tuner.
    • Centre the market on that estimate.
    • Set the width from your uncertainty, not as wide as possible.
    • Update the market as I trade with you or give you information.

Also in our technical interviews, on camera, with a score.

Concept 2 of 81 min

Adverse selection and the winner's curse

The rule
A market maker earns its spread on uninformed flow, loses to informed flow, and moves or widens its quotes when one side keeps trading.

The why, the charts, the worked example and the interview questions are in Essentials, with every quiz.

See the plansSign in

Concept 3 of 81 min

Managing inventory

The rule
A market maker long inventory lowers both its bid and its offer, and one that is short raises both.

The why, the charts, the worked example and the interview questions are in Essentials, with every quiz.

See the plansSign in

Concept 4 of 81 min

Expected values of dice and cards

The rule
Expected values add, and multiply for independent variables, but the expectation of a square is not the square of the expectation.

The why, the charts, the worked example and the interview questions are in Essentials, with every quiz.

See the plansSign in

Concept 5 of 81 min

Waiting times and optimal stopping

The rule
The number of failures before a first success with probability p averages (1 − p) ÷ p.

The why, the charts, the worked example and the interview questions are in Essentials, with every quiz.

See the plansSign in

Concept 6 of 81 min

Edge, fees and variance

The rule
A bet's edge is its expected value per unit staked, and fees are paid on every leg of a round trip.

The why, the charts, the worked example and the interview questions are in Essentials, with every quiz.

See the plansSign in

Concept 7 of 81 min

Kelly sizing

The rule
The Kelly criterion stakes the fraction (b × p − q) ÷ b of the bankroll, the edge divided by the odds.

The why, the charts, the worked example and the interview questions are in Essentials, with every quiz.

See the plansSign in

Concept 8 of 81 min

AdvancedWhere the break-even quotes sit when some traders know

The rule
A market maker sets its offer at the expected value given a buy and its bid at the expected value given a sell.

The why, the charts, the worked example and the interview questions are in Essentials, with every quiz.

See the plansSign in

Recap

  • Centre your market on expected value, quote both sides tightly around it, and widen for size or uncertainty.
  • A trade against you is information: someone who keeps buying is telling you your price is too low.
  • Long inventory: lower both quotes; short: raise both.
  • Expected value is linear, but E[X²] is not E[X]²; condition on everything you are shown.
  • Kelly stakes (b × p − q) ÷ b of the bankroll, about μ ÷ σ² for small edges; most traders bet a fraction of it.
Now test it

25 questions on Market-making and trading games

Timed, like the real one, drawn from a bank of 33. Every answer explained.

Test yourself →